does it get better than Anguilla? 🤔

Moderately well-travelled for the Caribbean region and wondering: is Anguilla the best out there for clear turquoise water and relatively undeveloped beaches? I like to go to islands I haven’t been to, yet every time it just seems like im thinking, ‘Well Anguilla was perfect.’ Anyone have suggestions for lesser known spots similar to the pic I added? ISO: Uncrowded, ocean water looks like a pool, sand is sugary 🩵