Caribbean Resort Help – Looking for Seclusion + Amazing Beaches

Hi all – My wife and I are looking to spend 6 nights in the Caribbean in November and are looking for resort recommendations. 12 years ago we stayed at Palm Island in St. Vincent and the Grenadines for our honeymoon and we sadly haven’t been back to the Caribbean since. The island was magical and we’d like to find something similar that prioritizes world class beaches and water, a feeling of seclusion/remoteness, beachfront accommodations, and good food. So far the leader in the club house is Peter Island Resort in BVI. We’re hoping to spend around $10k on room/food for the 6 nights. Would greatly appreciate any reviews of Peter Island or other recommendations. Thanks in advance!