Aurora Anguilla or Half Moon Bay Jamaica

My family and I have thoroughly researched both of these destinations and are ready to book. We are torn between these two final contenders and would love input from those who have visited one or both! We are traveling with a two year old. Our trip will be scheduled for mid March 2027. Getting there is not an issue, we have direct flights available from international airports near us. So really it’s just which spot fits our family better. I get more of an easy going, boutique feel from Half Moon, but I love all the activities available at Aurora. Please share your thoughts! Thank you!