20 Year Anniversary Trip Recommendations

My husband and I will be taking a trip for our 20th anniversary in June 2027 and are starting to plan. We would love recommendations on a resort/boutique hotel that might fit all of these wants anywhere within the Caribbean:

1. Adults only

2. Private beach (with ocean view room options)

3. Warm clear somewhat calm water

4. All inclusive with good food/drinks or walkable to a variety of restaurants, bars, and shops safely

5. Under $7k for 5-6 nights including flights from MKE

6. Not a massive resort that we have to fight to get a beach/pool chair at

7. Can fly in commercially (no small planes or boats required to get there unless its included in booking and isn’t hours and hours duration)

8. Won’t have communication issues for English speakers (I wish my brain could have picked up another language)

9. Prefer to avoid Cancun/Rivera Maya as we have been multiple times

10. Prefer to avoid areas heavily impacted by saragassum if possible (again understand nature cannot be controlled but some areas have more based on currents etc)

We currently have Excellence Oyster Bay Jamaica (Montego Bay) bookmarked, but the beach/water seems of have a lot of sea grass and some safety concerns (a few reviews about break ins and seeing some warnings about Jamaica in general) but see mixed opinions on this.

Spam me with your recommendations if you know of a good fit or have feedback on Excellence Oyster Bay, thank you!