Bachelorette Party Ideas

Starting to brainstorm bachelorette party ideas for likely mid-late spring 2026 (March-May timeframe)

Likely around 6-10 girls, mid 30s, all have passports already. Travel would be from nyc (most), Atlanta, Minneapolis. Likely ~3-5 nights so nowhere that’s going to require 10+ hours flying time

Think more fruity drinks by the pool, rooftop cocktail bar, wine night etc. — not wild drunken club nights. More Napa than Vegas vibe-wise, if that makes sense. Would like to have some tasty drinks but not necessarily looking to get blackout wasted

Would prefer somewhere new. Have been to St Lucia, Aruba, Barbados, Dominican Republic, Bahamas, Puerto Rico – so would ideally prefer to avoid those.

Open to multiple hotel rooms or villa but lean more resort over Airbnb/VRBO for amenities reasons – somewhere with a swim up bar and/or ability to order drinks poolside or at beach loungers/palapa etc. Would lean towards an option where we can go off-property for dinner/drinks if we like rather than an all inclusive but not entirely opposed to the latter

Somewhere with options for activities besides just sitting by the pool also – boat ride/snorkeling, maybe hiking, etc

Any thoughts come to mind? Was initially intrigued by Grand Cayman or Antigua but overwhelmed by all the islands to consider