Exuma or Curaçao honeymoon?

Hey everyone!

My fiance and I are planning our honeymoon from Sept 12-27. We’re debating between Exuma Bahamas and Curaçao.

We’re looking to have a relaxing experience overall with beautiful beaches, clear water, and delicious food/drinks. Usually we travel with a more adventure-oriented goals, but for our honeymoon don’t have any real strenuous goals.

So far our thoughts are-
Exuma (we’d stay in Georgetown or One Tar Bay, or open to other suggestions!)

We’d be interested in visiting the
– unmatched sandbars (man o war, pipe creek)
– Deans blue hole
– Thunderball grotto

But upon further research we have some concerns about the already limited food options being further narrowed by September/off season closures. This has made us consider Curaçao (which has the added benefit of not being mid-hurricane season). The active reef life seems to be a trade off for the sandbars and there seems to be some more adventurous rocky coastal landscapes (we are both climbers). Would you recommend Curaçao over the Bahamas in September due to closures, food diversity and our interests?

(As a side not we’ve also been considering Hawaii which is a much farther flight for us. We are working with a 1-2 week timeframe)