Island / Resort Similar to The Buc on St. Croix?

We stayed in St. Croix at the Buccaneer last year and literally had the best trip of our lives. We did everything you could do in 7 days – from beer drinking pigs to tidal pools to snorkeling the pier to hiking / swimming at Isaac’s Bay. We fell in love with the Island, the wonderful people there and everything about it.

We want to try out another island this year with a similar vibe and hopefully find a resort that’s as charming as the Buccaneer.

What we loved about The Buc:

1. Kids could walk to the beach alone and play
2. Breakfast buffet was perfect to start the day
3. Centrally located so we could get to everything with a car
4. Rooms were nice but not overly done
5. Staff was amazing
6. Multiple beaches on property, snorkeling from shore, etc.

We don’t need nightlife, 5 star restaurants or entertainment as almost our entire days were spent exploring the island’s beaches, reefs and outdoor activities. The Buc was great as we were able to have a nice room and as stated above – kids could get to the beach and swim in between adventures. Breakfast was amazing as well – but we ate all but 1 of our meals at local restaurants.

Snorkeling, hiking, waterfall chasing, meeting the local folks, etc. – this is what the vacation’s about.

Thank you in advance!