Recommendation for next island

Hey everyone,

I’m a big fan of the Caribbean and so far I’ve visited Antigua and Barbuda, Grand Cayman and Little Cayman, Turks and Caicos, Aruba, Jamaica, the Dominican Republic, Cuba, Mexico, Sint Maarten, and Anguilla.

I completely fell in love with Anguilla — it’s the only island I’ve visited twice. I loved everything about it: the beaches, the food, the people, and especially the fact that it didn’t feel overly touristy.

Antigua and Barbuda was another favorite for similar reasons.

Now I’d love to explore more islands, but I’m a little worried about being disappointed after such amazing experiences. Based on my favorites, are there any other islands you think I’d enjoy that have a similar vibe?

Thanks so much for your time and insights!

Edit: we usually get an airbnb, rent a car and love to explore.