Traveling with kids to the Caribbean !

Hello! We are taking our two kids (7 and 3) to the Caribbean for a nice one week vacation during thanksgiving week! We have been to the Turks and Caicos and absolutely love it , but my wife wants to try something different and is considering Atlantis in the Bahamas for a more kid centered experience. I’m more of the type that likes the freedom to roam and really good food and service , I don’t like the manufactured experiences that ultra resorts have to offer . I’m trying to convince her to go back to the Turks ! Is giving Atlantis Bahamas a shot worth it? Or does anyone have any other recommendations on family friendly spots ! Please let me know !